Wednesday, August 15, 2007

DAY 15: The Color Purple (1985)

In reaching the halfway point of "31 Days of Spielberg" we arrive at a significant shift in the life of the famous director. As he approached his fortieth birthday, Spielberg felt the desire to want to tell more dramatic, character-driven stories free of any fantasy elements and special effects. If one were to characterize Spielberg’s career as a “journey” (which I have), that journey can be almost neatly divided into three distinct "phases" which, not coincidentally I think, correspond perfectly with three stages of human development. If the early period of his career can be called his professional “childhood” and the later part (from Schindler’s List on) his “adulthood,” then The Color Purple was about to bring Spielberg into his artistic “adolescence,” a time where he desperately wanted to “grow up” and be taken more seriously as a filmmaker but, in spite of his enormous talent, still lacked the maturity, perspective and responsibility of being able to deal in heavier subject matter with anything other than juvenile sensebilities.

The Color Purple began its long and eventful "life" as a Pulliter Prize-winning novel by Alice Walker. Basing it partially on the experiences of her own ancestors, the book told the story (through letters and diary entries) of a poor, uneducated black girl named Celie growing up in the American South of the early-to-mid 1900's and deals with the many trials and hardships she faces. Spielberg friend and producing partner Kathleen Kennedy read the book and, knowing that the director wanted to explore different kinds of projects, suggested Steven read it. He did and was so struck by it that he felt he wanted to try his at hand at bringing the story to the big screen. Learning that Warner Bros. had already optioned the rights Spielberg went about the task of trying to get hired as director. However, leery of Hollywood's track record depicting of African-Americans, author Walker had made sure that she retained approval of the script, actors and director. Thus, for the first time in a long while Spielberg had to "audition" for the job. He met with Walker and she was so taken with his enthusiasm (in addition to which she had seen and loved the movie E.T.) that she gave Steven her blessing. Shortly thereafter, Spielberg had second thoughts about being the right one for the job--thinking perhaps the story would be better told by a black director or a woman--and voiced his concern to Quincy Jones who encouraged Spielberg by claiming that he didn't have to be an alien to direct E.T.

As he had Peter Benchley do on Jaws, Spielberg asked Walker if she would be interested in adapting her own novel for the screen. Reluctantly, Walker agreed and penned a screenpla--which, interestingly, she entitled Look For Me in the Sunset--that she ended up being so dissatisfied with that she begged Spielberg not to use it (though she did end up very involved in the filmmaking process, being on the set quite a bit serving as consultant). The script was instead written by Dutch-born Menno Meyjes (who wrote the teleplay to the Amazing Stories episode "The Mission"). Once again, Allen Daviau served as cinematographer and Michael Kahn edited the picture but there was one notable absence from Spielberg's usual filmmaking "company": composer John Williams. Although it wasn't the first time Spielberg hadn't used Williams since Sugarland Express (both the "Kick the Can" segment of Twilight Zone and Poltergiest were scored by Jerry Goldsmith) it was the first--and as it turned out only--feature film directed solely by Spielberg to not feature a Williams score. Instead Spielberg employed the musical talents of co-producer Quincy Jones. The interesting thing about this switch, though, is that the result is still very "Williams-esque" in style and tone, which seems to suggest that regardless of who scores a Spielberg film, the material invariably inspires a uniquely "Spielbergian" sound.

In casting the film, Spielberg followed his usual philosophy of hiring the people that he thought worked best in the roles, even if they were relatively new and inexperienced. Comedienne Whoopi Goldberg (in her debut acting role) was given the seminal part of Celie, Witness and Places in the Heart star Danny Glover played the abusive "Mister," another first-time actress named Oprah Winfrey played the fiery Sofia, Willard E. Pugh played Sofia's husband Harpo (which, ironically, is "Oprah" spelled backwards) and Margaret Avery played the beautiful blues singer Shug Avery. Coincidentally, Spielberg had already worked with Avery over 12 years earlier in his made-for-TV movie Something Evil (in which she played a very small part).

Filming began in July of 1985 and even before production started, the film was surrounded by controversy. Legrad H. Clegg II, head of a group called the Coalition Against Black Exploitation, said: "The elevation of Alice Walker's book to the status of a movie will be devastating to the black community. The book's degradation of the black male and its subtle promotion of lesbianism as an alternative to failed heterosexual relationships conveys a negative message that is destructive to the black family." When Clegg's group demanded a prescreeing of the film and was turned down, there were demonstrations outside the offices of Quincy Jones.

On the other side of the controversy, however, stood passionate proponents of the book who were extremely skeptical that Spielberg (a white Jewish male known for his sentinemtality) was the best choice to direct a dark, gritty story of a victimized black woman. Despite his own doubts Spielberg took a defensive position: "The issue was not the color of my skin but whether I'd make a good movie out of the book." His comments about understanding the pangs of prejudice due to his own bouts with anti-Semitism as a child (though he tried to make clear that his childhood troubles didn't even come close to approaching the level of the character Celie's) probably didn't do much to ease the concerns of his detractors.

Another source of contention was the film's treatment of homosexuality (a significant element in the book). Feeling at the time that mainstream audiences would not be ready for a scene where a woman de-flowers another woman, Spielberg chose to stage the scene between Celie and Shug in a far more subtle and ambiguous (and in his words "poetic") manner. In the film the two merely share a kiss, but whether it is a kiss of romantic love or of simple affection is never made clear. While that approach might have appealed more to conservative theatregoers, while upsetting more liberal ones, it has been said that the decision was based less on Spielberg's discomfort and more on mere fiscal intentions, i.e. to make a PG-13 film rather than an R film allowing more people to see it and, consequently, earning the film more money. It definitely did little to allay the common criticism of Spielberg that his films were devoid of any kind of sex, straight or otherwise. Although at the time Walker was none too pleased with the end result, she eventually decided that she liked the way the scene was done (finding that it emphasized the "sweetness" of the relationship more). In an interesting twist of fate, Spielberg has regretted not going for a more frank and honest interpretation of that exchange.

Another problem Spielberg discovered in the filming of the movie was how hard it was to represent the actual color purple on screen (early on Spielberg had toyed with the idea of shooting The Color Purple in black-and-white but quickly decided that it wouldn't work). The opening sequence, set in a field of flowers, provided particular difficulty as the flowers that were planted were called purple on the packages the seeds came in, but ended up looking more pink. Enormous amounts of discussion occurred over what really was purple and what was pink. The filmmakers ultimately ended up spray-painting a number of the flowers that were closer to the camera (a problem that could easily be solved today digitally) and Daviau had to go into the lab and "re-time" everything to get it to turn out right. In the end, Spielberg was never completely happy with the result.

Despite the tremendous difference between the film's intense subject matter (rape, incest, abuse, racism, etc) and Spielberg's usual fare, it does contain a few of the director's recurring themes. Certainly family is central in The Color Purple (particularly family dysfunction which is probably more potent here than in any other Spielberg story). In fact, in a fascinating bit of providence--of life imitating art--on the day Spielberg shot the film's birth scene, his then wife Amy Irving went into labor and eventually gave birth to Spielberg's firstborn child Max (later, Spielberg used the sound of his own son crying for the newborn infant in the scene). There is also a very strong motherly thread running through the entire story as Celie tries to find the children that she had by her father. Finally, Celie's talk of God and the afterlife (she addresses all of her letters to him) as well as Sofia's eventual affirmation of God's existence near the end of the movie both come back to the religious/metaphysical themes that appear in numerous Spielberg films.

Though the movie was heavily criticized upon its release, it was nonetheless nominated for 11 Oscars. Interestingly, it didn't receive a single one (tying it with 1977's The Turning Point for the record of the most nominations without a win). One of the most bizarre exclusions, though, was the ignoring of Spielberg as director. This was a particularly harsh snub and caused yet another stir for a film that already had its fair share of controversy. While people who worked on the film expressed disbelief and sadness that Spielberg wasn't recognized for the rather sizable part he played in bringing The Color Purple to the big screen, they all still felt priveleged to have been involved in it and even now speak very highly of Spielberg as a director (with Danny Glover actually expressing admiration for Spielberg's "courage"). The experience seemed to be a pleasant one for everyone involved. Many years later, in fact, Oprah Winfrey and Quincy Jones chose to revisit the story of Celie, Shug and Nettie in a Broadway stage musical version of The Color Purple that they produced. The show has won numerous awards and still tours the country today.

After all the accolades and criticisms, all the love and controversy, all the behind-the-scenes stories and the passage of over twenty years, the film today is itself a bit of a mixed bag. It's a good--though certainly not a great--Spielberg movie. As usual, it cannot be faulted at all from a technical standpoint (Spielberg's use of transitions between scenes are among the best he's ever used). The staging of scenes, though many feel mechanical in nature, is at times impeccable. The moment when Danny Glover's "Mister" throws young Celie's sister out of the house is particularly effective (Spielberg's direction to the young actress playing Nettie was simply: "Whatever happens, don't let him separate the two of you."). It even resulted in a powerful and unscripted moment where the girl playing Nettie screamed out "WHY? WHY?". Also, the look of the movie is quite stunning and gorgeous. In fact, it is almost too beautiful given the nature of the film's content (it feels at times sort of surreal) and Spielberg's abounding optimism and necessity to be positive make for a very confused finished product. His heavy-handed sentimentality, appropriate perhaps in fantasy films like Close Encounters and E.T., comes off as more pedantic and preachy and despite some strong character development at various points in the story (Spielberg did want to make a movie that was only about people after all), several characterizations come off as exeggarted and cartoony. Nevertheless, there are many moving moments throughout. The finale, where Celie and Nettie are reuinted, is actually quite extraordinary. Roger Ebert wrote about the scene: "The affirmation at the end of the film is so joyous that this is one of the few movies in a long time that inspires tears of happiness, and earns them... It is one of the great heart-rending moments in the movies." Indeed, upon reviewing it recently I still found myself (in spite of my own reluctance and the numerous glaring flaws in the film) tearing up once or twice.

Many have spoken about the important impact the film had on the inclusion of more African-American actors and black-themed stories in major big-budget Hollywood movies and that is certainly nothing to be dismissed. The film also represents, in my opinion, the best acting work ever done by both Whoopi Goldberg and Oprah Winfrey (of which they are, to this day, very proud) who were both included among the many Oscar nominations the film received. As far as the impact of the film on Spielberg's life/career, The Color Purple represents his first attempt to "break out" of his normal comfort zone. Spielberg took a tremendous risk with The Color Purple and although it might not have completely worked out at the time, one can't blame him for trying to challenge himself as an artist, to strech his cinematic talents and push himself into new and provocative areas. It was the first step in a direction that would ultimately result in some of his best work, which lay not too far ahead.





TOMORROW: Spielberg's Empire

23 comments:

Joe Valdez said...

Alan's comment about how Indiana Jones is still better than 72% of the adventure movies made by other directors comes to mind here.

The Color Purple - for its flaws - is still so much better than Shakespeare In Love or A Beautiful Mind or any of the blatantly superficial dramas making that run for Academy Awards at the end of the year.

The reason is the craftsmanship. Allen Daviau's lightning is brilliant. This cast is undeniably great, particularly Oprah Winfrey. And I thought Spielberg handled the material with a lot more dignity than we see today. It would have been easy for him to do A Guy Named Joe instead of challenging himself with a project with this degree of difficulty.

dwhite10701 said...

I appreciate your work on this project, Damian, and I'm sure it's just a ton of work. But I have to say, I was really looking forward to your discussion of this movie, yet your essay seems kinda slight compared to the previous entries.

Edward Copeland said...

I remember how excited The Color Purple made me when I first saw it, especially after the disappointment of Temple of Doom. Finally, Spielberg grows up, I thought. I remember the outrage I felt when the Academy snubbed him and the film. While I still think the film is good, over the years, its flaws have become more apparent and it really wasn't until Schindler's List that Spielberg was able to get rid of some of his negative habits.

odienator said...

In the Spielberg canon, this is my E.T.--the movie everyone thinks is too syrupy and saccharine but me. I read the book before I'd seen the movie, and I didn't think Spielberg could pull it off. While it would have been interesting to see what the post-Schindler's List Spielberg could have made with this film, I'm perfectly fine with the way it turned out.

My favorite Spielberg moment is here, courtesy of Oprah. If Celie is the movie's soul, Sofia is the movie's fire, which is why to me her story arc is the most heartbreaking. Celie acquires strength where there was none, which is easier to deal with than being stripped of it as Sofia was.

I thought the movie's prettiness was visual commentary. Here was such beautiful scenery and Celie was in such an ugly predicament that she couldn't notice. It ties into that line about pissing God off if one does not notice the color purple.

There are flaws in the movie to be sure: it plays too innocently about some things and doesn't allow Mister to be as complex as he is in Walker's novel. I don't think those have gotten any bigger since I first saw the film, but as Joe V. says, it is marvelously crafted, acted and allowed more dignity than one might expect for its subject matter. It has a little bit of everything, like an old fashioned studio picture or something out of Bollywood. Despite Spielberg's muting of some of the more unsavory aspects, the film inspired real emotion in me, joy, tears and anger, just like Walker's novel.

gonzalo said...

I believe Spielberg first appeared on the cover of Time magazine due to The Color Purple. I remember that at that time Spielberg said that He didn't storyboarded the film, which was a first for him. This is astonishing due to the master transisions Spielberg makes in the movie, as Damian rightly points out.

Jeffrey said...

"Oprah Winfrey and Quincy Jones chose to revisit the story of Celie, Shug and Nettie in a Broadway stage musical..."

This, to me, even more than 1941, should have been Spielberg's musical.

Damian said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Damian said...

Odie:

That was beautifully said. I think you might've been more the one more qualified to write about this film than I was.

Jeffrey said...

Hmm.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/be/The_Color_Purple_poster.jpg

&

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/08/Munich_1_Poster.jpg

Not to mention:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/6/66/E_t_the_extra_terrestrial_ver3.jpg

&

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/38/Schindler%27s_List_movie.jpg

Interesting.

Damian said...

Jeffrey:

Since I own both of them, I noticed the similarity between the E.T. and Schindler's List posters a while ago (and was actually planning to write about in my Schindler essay) but I never caught the similarity between the Color Purple and Munich one-sheets.

Good eye. :)

Anonymous said...

"Since I own both of them, I noticed the similarity between the E.T. and Schindler's List posters a while ago (and was actually planning to write about in my Schindler essay) but I never caught the similarity between the Color Purple and Munich one-sheets."

I have actually noticed both of these similarities between the posters. I am glad someone else brought it up and noticed it as well. I wasn't sure if it was just me or if they really were sort of simular.

~ Juli

Megan said...

Well heck my post got lost in the ether. I will try to recreate it. If it shows up later, I apologize for posting twice (and my first one was better).

I agree that TCP is 'almost too beautiful given the nature of the film's content.' I haven't seen it in years, but I remember the scene when Celie first sees Mister's kitchen. Yes, it is a very dirty kitchen, but to me it looked more like one of those puzzles where one has to stack a brick without knocking the structure over, rather than the filthy pile of drudgery it was supposed to be (and by extension, an idea of what marriage to Mister was going to be like). It looked dirty, but it didn't FEEL dirty.

I remember one of your posts Damian where you talked about how you prefer not to read the book before seeing the movie. I didn't agree with you at first, but I am coming around to that opinion. I have realized that as a reader first and a filmgoer second, the film almost always comes off second best (but that's just me, and TCP was a book that made a huge impact on my 15 year old sensibilities).

But in spite of that I did really like it as a whole. I cried like a baby at the end. For a film that was made during his 'adolescence' Spielberg did a pretty darn good job. I am still surprised he wasn't nominated for director considering the performances he got from his (mostly) inexperienced actors.

Keep up the great work Damian. Drink your vitamin C and get as much rest as you can, because I can't wait to read some of the upcoming essays.

Tucker said...

Great work Damian! Congrats on getting half way. I know this is a lot to do, and if you're writing each essay each day, then I know the pressure is on. But don't give up. This project of yours is very much worth the effort and I believe you will be greatly pleased once you have finished. I also think you are creating one of the most significant film-blog (even art-blog, broadly speaking) contributions this year (at least). It is easy for folks to spout off about their tastes, it is another to dive deeply into the entire life's work of a particular artist and lay the groundwork for your own (reasoned) opinions. Keep up the good work.

Damian said...

Thank you, Tuck.

Coming from you that means a lot.

:)

odienator said...

Damian, thank you for your comment, but you're doing a damn fine job of this yourself. I admire your stamina. I was going to do something like this on Spike Lee (who has made some movies I love and some I did not like at all). If you don't collapse at the end of this 31 days of Spielberg, I might consider doing my Lee joint. If, however, they cart you off to the loony bin at the end, I think I'll write about the films Charles Laughton directed. :)

Matt Zoller Seitz said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Damian said...

dvwhite:

One of the things this project has taught me is that for every Spielberg film that exists there is at least one person out there who values it far above the rest. For this reason I have tried to devote if not equal time and space to the discussion fo each work, at least comparable energy and passion. I admit I have not always succeeded and The Color Purple was a film that I admit suffered somewhat in the run of things. As I say in my essay, I like the film but do not love it and so my energy probably waned somewhat in the writing of it. I certainly could have said more but in a way I am "saving up" for a few of the titles that are upcoming. I had a number of essays already written when the month started and have been writing along the way. Curently, however, I am caught up and am basically writing one of these a day now. You are correct in that it is a LOT of work and, in addition to my day job, takes a lot of my time. My passion for the project hasn't declined in any way, but (as I predicted) I am starting to feel as Spielberg felt in the middle of Jaws as I ask myself "What have I gotten myself into?"

雪花 said...

福~
「朵
語‧,最一件事,就。好,你西...............................................................................................................................-...相互
,以讓>它使...................

products said...

China Wholesale has been described as the world’s factory. This phenomenom is typified by the rise ofbusiness. Incredible range of products available with China Wholesalers “Low Price and High Quality” not only reaches directly to their target clients worldwide but also ensures that wholesale from china from China means margins you cannot find elsewhere and buy products wholesaleChina Wholesale will skyroket your profits.wedding dressescheap naruto cosplayanime cosplay

products said...

Women’s nike tn Shox Rivalry est le modèle féminin le plus tendance de baskets pour le sport. tn chaussuresConcernant la semelle :Cheap Brand Jeans Shop - True Religion Jeans nike shoes & Puma Shoes Online- tn nike,Diesel Jeans le caoutchouc extérieur, l’EVA intermédiaire Levis Jeanset le textile intérieur s’associent pour attribuer à la.ed hardy shirts pretty fitCharlestoncheap columbia jackets. turned a pair of double plays to do the trick.Lacoste Polo Shirts, puma basket, Burberry Polo Shirts.wholesale Lacoste polo shirts and cheap polo shirtswith great price.Thank you so much!!cheap polo shirts men'ssweate,gillette mach3 razor bladesfor men.As for Cheap Evisu JeansCheap Armani Jeans

Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

hanly said...

Blu Ray Converter
Convert Blu Ray Mac
Convert Blu Ray to AVI
Convert Blu Ray to DivX
Convert Blu Ray to MKV
Convert Blu Ray to MOV
Convert Blu Ray to MP4
Convert Blu Ray to MPEG
Convert Blu Ray to MPEG2
Convert Blu Ray to MPEG4
Convert Blu Ray to VOB
Convert Blu Ray to WMV
Convert Blu Ray to Xvid
Convert Blu Ray to HD
Convert Blu Ray to HD WMV
Convert Blu Ray to iPod
Convert Blu Ray to PS3
Convert Blu Ray to PSP
Convert Blu Ray to Xbox360

dfadf said...

Microsoft Office
Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Office 2010 key
Office 2010 download
Office 2010 Professional
Microsoft outlook
Outlook 2010
Windows 7
Microsoft outlook 2010